The Midday Report with Mandy Wiener

The Midday Report with Mandy Wiener

National and international news and current affairs updated at midday each weekday.
00:00
00:00

Resumen del episodio

The Western Cape High Court is currently hearing legal challenges against the Land Expropriation Act, brought by applicants including the Democratic Alliance, Afri Forum, and the Institute for Race Relations. The litigation focuses on whether specific clauses within the Act are unconstitutional, particularly regarding the balance between private property protection and land reform. Key points of contention include Section 12, which outlines circumstances for expropriation without compensation, and Section 19, which allows the state to proceed with expropriation while compensation negotiations are ongoing. The discussion explores the legal concept of 'reading in' as a remedy for irrationality, a proposal the President has suggested to address flaws in the Act. However, applicants argue that such a remedy lacks clarity and may exceed judicial mandate. The debate also touches upon the broader political impasse regarding the fundamental legitimacy of expropriation without compensation in South African law.

Capítulos

Haz clic en un capítulo para ir directamente a ese momento

Destacados

The argument goes that that list where expropriation without compensation may happen might be interpreted as not a closed list and that it may potentially extend the state power to put in more circumstances under which expropriation without compensation could happen.

00:01:42 · The speaker explains the primary legal concern regarding the wording of Section 12.

The president has actually admitted this in court papers. He agrees that it's irrational.

00:02:58 · The speaker highlights a significant concession made by the President regarding the Act's wording.

When I heard the argument earlier on was that there's about nine different versions around how the reading in should happen.

00:04:09 · The speaker notes the lack of consensus and clarity regarding the proposed judicial remedy.

The political issue really, Mandy, if you dig deeper, is that there is no agreement on expropriation without compensation as a concept.

00:06:20 · The speaker identifies the fundamental ideological divide driving the legal dispute.

Episodios

10721-

Land Expropriation Act challenged

The Western Cape High Court is currently hearing legal challenges against the Land Expropriation Act, brought by applicants including the Democratic Alliance, Afri Forum, and the Institute for Race Relations. The litigation focuses on whether specific clauses within the Act are unconstitutional, particularly regarding the balance between private property protection and land reform. Key points of contention include Section 12, which outlines circumstances for expropriation without compensation, and Section 19, which allows the state to proceed with expropriation while compensation negotiations are ongoing. The discussion explores the legal concept of 'reading in' as a remedy for irrationality, a proposal the President has suggested to address flaws in the Act. However, applicants argue that such a remedy lacks clarity and may exceed judicial mandate. The debate also touches upon the broader political impasse regarding the fundamental legitimacy of expropriation without compensation in South African law.

03 ago. 2026
10720-

A new witness is expected to testify in the trial against Nosiviwe Mapisa Nqakula

This news report covers ongoing criminal trials, focusing specifically on the case involving former Defence Minister and former Speaker of the National Assembly, Nosibube Mapisa-Nkakula. Reporter Komotsu Modise provides updates on the testimony regarding alleged corruption and bribery involving Numbasa Nzondwa Nzobu. The report details the appearance of Noel Nzobu, a senior military doctor and husband to the accused, whose testimony is central to determining if he can corroborate claims regarding the delivery of bribe money to the minister.

03 ago. 2026
10719-

Cape Town Mayor announces new policing powers for Metro Police

Cape Town Mayor Jordan Hill Lewis has formally declared an intergovernmental dispute with the acting minister of police regarding the refusal to grant investigative powers to the Metro Police. The dispute centers on a long-running battle over the devolution of policing authority and the city's desire to expand the capabilities of its municipal officers to assist the South African Police Service (SAPS).

03 ago. 2026
10718-

NPA’s six mouth plan to turn IDAC around

An interview with Kaiser Ghaniago, spokesperson for the National Prosecuting Authority (NPA), regarding the six-month plan to reset the Investigating Directorate (IDAC). The discussion covers recent announcements from the Justice Minister and the NDPP, Andy Motibi, concerning structural reforms, rebranding, and operational audits. Key focus areas include lifestyle audits for prosecutors and investigators, human resource management, case audits, and addressing governance failures within the entity.

03 ago. 2026
10717-

Vusi Matlala and co-accused trial within trial continues

Reporter Demokatsu Lashoro provides an update on the Kat Magala trial within a trial, focusing on the testimony of Captain Sohobela during his sixth day on the stand. The report covers the cross-examination regarding police standing orders from 2015 and potential contraventions of the Criminal Procedure Act, specifically concerning crime scene management and the immediate transport of suspects to police stations. The discussion explores legal arguments surrounding the lawfulness of an arrest, including whether there was reasonable suspicion for a vehicle search and the lack of mention regarding the murder of Amman Swat during the initial arrest. The coverage also touches upon the legality of search and seizure operations conducted without a warrant at the property of Kekane.

03 ago. 2026